'Homebound' Oscar Nomination Highlights Plight of Marginalized in Modi's India
A film depicting the friendship between a Muslim man and a Dalit during the pandemic exposes systemic inequalities exacerbated by Hindu nationalist policies.

DEVARI, India – 'Homebound,' a film chronicling the bond between two friends during India’s COVID-19 crisis, has earned an Oscar shortlist nomination, bringing renewed attention to the struggles of marginalized communities under Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government. The film, directed by Neeraj Ghaywan, is based on the true story of Mohammad Saiyub, a Muslim, and Amrit Kumar, a Dalit – formerly considered 'untouchable' under the caste system – who were forced to walk nearly 1,000 miles home after the pandemic lockdown. A photograph of Saiyub caring for Kumar, who had fallen ill, went viral, encapsulating the desperate situation faced by millions of migrant workers.
The film shines a light on the systemic discrimination faced by Muslims and Dalits in India, which has intensified during the decade of Hindu nationalist rule by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). The Modi government's response to the pandemic disproportionately impacted vulnerable populations, leaving them stranded without resources or support. 'Homebound' portrays the everyday realities of this injustice, showing how deeply ingrained prejudice intersects with economic hardship.
Director Neeraj Ghaywan feared that the film's message might be suppressed due to the current political climate. The fact that Martin Scorsese, the film's executive producer, had to work under a code name ('elder brother') underscores the chilling effect of censorship and the risks associated with challenging the dominant narrative. Ghaywan’s caution reflects the increasing intolerance towards dissenting voices in India.
The film is adapted from a New York Times essay by Basharat Peer, who was struck by the photograph's depiction of 'care and dignity' in the face of adversity. Peer recognized the significance of the men's religious identities within the context of rising Islamophobia fueled by Hindu nationalist rhetoric. The film serves as a powerful counter-narrative to the divisive rhetoric often promoted by the BJP and its supporters.
The normalization of anti-Muslim sentiment has been widely documented, with instances of hate speech and violence becoming increasingly common. In February, the chief minister of Assam, Himanta Biswa Sarma, a member of the BJP, shared an AI-generated video depicting violence against Muslims, demonstrating the party's willingness to use inflammatory content to further its agenda. This incident, and others like it, contribute to a climate of fear and marginalization for Muslim communities.
'Homebound' exposes the human cost of these policies, highlighting the urgent need for social justice and equality. The film's success in reaching the Oscar shortlist offers a platform to amplify the voices of those who are often silenced. It challenges viewers to confront the uncomfortable truths about inequality and to demand accountability from those in power.
The film’s portrayal of the struggles faced by Saiyub and Kumar, both garment factory workers, underscores the precariousness of life for many low-wage workers in India. The government's sudden lockdown left millions without income or shelter, forcing them to undertake perilous journeys to return to their villages. 'Homebound' is a reminder of the need for policies that protect workers' rights and ensure a safety net for those most vulnerable to economic shocks.
The film is a testament to the enduring power of human connection in the face of oppression. It celebrates the resilience of marginalized communities and the importance of solidarity across religious and caste lines. By telling the story of Saiyub and Kumar, 'Homebound' offers a message of hope and resistance in a time of increasing division.
The movie serves as a call to action, urging viewers to engage in critical reflection and to support movements for social change. Its international recognition provides an opportunity to challenge the narratives of hate and division and to promote a more just and equitable society for all.


